In the landmark case of lincoln mills, the supreme court ordered that ________.
|
1. Describe how the legal foundation for arbitration as it exists today in the United States was developed. The first mention of labor arbitration in American labor history dates to a clause in the constitution of the journey men Cabinet Makers of Philadelphia in 1829. The earliest arbitration hearing was in 1865 when ironworkers in Pittsburg arbitrated their wages. The first known case for using outside arbitrator was in 1871 in eastern Ohio. The Lincoln Mills Case is considered a
landmark decision in arbitration. In this case Supreme Court ordered an employer to arbitrate grievances as provided for in a collective bargaining agreement that stated an employer’s agreement to arbitrate grievance disputes was a tradeoff for unions agreement…show more content… Show Annotation Primary Holding For labor disputes involving federal rights, federal courts are free to construct a federal law that governs labor contracts. Facts Textile Workers Union had a collective bargaining agreement with Lincoln Mills, which provided that arbitration would be used to resolve disputes regarding their relationship. It sued in federal court under Section 301(a) of the Taft-Hartley Act to compel Lincoln Mills to submit to arbitration. This law allows federal courts to hear cases based on violations of labor-management agreements that affect interstate commerce. Lincoln Mills argued that Congress had acted unconstitutionality in making this grant of jurisdiction. Opinions Majority
This grant of jurisdiction is constitutional because it is limited to cases that arise under federal common law, which by definition is federal law. Concurrence
Cases brought under this law do not rely on federal law as the substantive law that they apply. Enforcing the law involves some federal rights, however, so it is constitutional as part of a congressional grant of protective jurisdiction to federal courts. Dissent
Article III does not support the protective jurisdiction theory, which would allow Congress to give federal courts jurisdiction over applications of state laws and state court precedents. This is not a true form of federal question jurisdiction, especially since taking this theory to its conclusion would result in federal courts hearing contract and tort cases if they relate to contracts that affect commerce. Article III does not allow federal courts to create a federal common law that controls collective bargaining agreements, merely on the basis that Congress provides them with this authority under a federal law. The possibility that federal courts may eventually have appellate jurisdiction over a case does not mean that they should have original jurisdiction over it. Case Commentary This decision illustrates how a grant of jurisdiction to the federal courts enables them to create new forms of substantive law. Even though this applies only in cases governed by federal questions, rather than diversity cases, it is historically significant. What arbitration means?Arbitration is a procedure in which a dispute is submitted, by agreement of the parties, to one or more arbitrators who make a binding decision on the dispute. In choosing arbitration, the parties opt for a private dispute resolution procedure instead of going to court.
Which of the following is an advantage of the process of arbitration quizlet?Which of the following is an advantage of arbitration over the litigation process? Both labor and management participate in the selection of the arbitrator.
Which of the following is a difference between interest arbitration and rights arbitration?Most interest arbitration in the United States occurs in the private sector, under compulsory statutes. Rights arbitration deals with the interpretation or application of current contract terms.
During which of the following steps is a grievance said to have moved from the formal to informal stage?During which of the following steps is a grievance said to have moved from the formal to informal stage? An employee completes a grievance form.
|
